TL;DR

  • Your needs really do shift by season — February you and July you run on different fuel.
  • The pull is to swap your pillars when the season changes. That's exactly what to resist.
  • What's actually shifting isn't the pillar — it's the expression of it. "Health" in winter looks different from summer; the pillar is the same.
  • The year-long hold is what makes seasonal data mean anything: a full cycle measured against the same five things.
  • If you genuinely picked wrong, the annual review is where you act on it. Not week six.

The pull to change pillars

Most people, a few weeks in, feel a quiet tug. A bad February week makes "Health" feel pointless. A burst of work pressure makes "Family" feel like a luxury they can't afford right now. A summer of travel makes the whole list feel like someone else's priorities. The instinct is to open the app and rewrite it.

Don't. That tug is the practice doing its job, not failing at it.

What seasons actually shift

It's true that your needs aren't constant. A February version of you in a dark country with a deadline is a different operating environment from a July version on annual leave. Energy moves. Attention moves. What feels possible moves.

But notice what's actually moving: the texture of your weeks, not the things you care about. You still care about your health in February — you just want to express it as "two walks and decent sleep" instead of "lift four times a week." You still care about family in a busy quarter — you just need a smaller version of the same pillar. The pillar isn't the problem; you're confusing it with its tactics.

Three layers, only one of which is yours to change

It helps to separate three things:

If you find yourself wanting to swap a pillar, what you almost always need to swap is the expression. Same pillar, smaller version, season-appropriate. That's the move.

Why the year-long hold matters most in the bad season

The pillar earns its keep precisely when you want to abandon it. Anyone can stick to "Health" in May when the days are long and the gym feels good. The point of the year-long commitment is that you're still working on Health in the dark week of November, when your body is tired and your motivation is gone, just in whatever smaller form you can manage.

That's not stubbornness. It's how you find out what the pillar actually means to you — by holding it through the season that wants you to drop it.

If you could swap pillars every time the weather changed, you'd never have data on the hard months. Twelve months of consistent measurement is what surfaces the real pattern: which pillars hold you up, which ones quietly drain, which ones you keep avoiding even when you have time.

What to do when you feel the pull

When the urge to change a pillar shows up, run this short test before doing anything:

  1. What's the smallest possible version of this pillar I could do this week? If you can name it, you don't have a pillar problem. You have an expression problem.
  2. Is the thing I want to swap to actually a value, or is it just what's loud right now? Most "I should care about X instead" feelings are reactive, not durable.
  3. Will this still feel urgent in six weeks? If no, it was the season talking. The pillar stays.

This is usually enough to settle it. The vast majority of pillar-doubts pass within a fortnight if you don't act on them.

The annual review is where pivots happen

None of this means you're stuck forever. The annual review exists for exactly this reason — to sit with twelve months of data and ask, honestly, which pillars belonged on the list. By then you'll know. The first three months only tell you which pillars feel hard; a full year tells you which ones actually carried you.

The hold isn't a trap. It's the only thing that makes the next pick a good one.

Related reading: Living authentically — how to be true to yourself · Our Why — the story behind My Lighthouse

← Back to all resources